When Government Screws Up Sorry You Usually Cant Sue Them
Eric F. Greenberg Attorney-at-Law
Today our topics are government organization, lawsuits, and tomatoes.
If theres any entity that is commonly the subject of complaint for not doing what its expected to do, its the US government. But can you actually sue the government for money damages if they, say, negligently perform their duties and that causes you losses?
Generally, the answer is no, because of an age-old principle called sovereign immunity. However, theres a law called the Federal Tort Claims Act that makes exceptions to sovereign immunity, that is, it lists situations in which you can in fact sue the government for negligently causing you damage.
Why does all this matter? First, because a food packager recently learned a hard lesson about the broad scope of the governments protection from getting sued, and second, because we might soon see changes to some of the principles and concepts that have long guided the organization and accountability of our government.
If youre a packager of food or other FDA-regulated products and have ever been confronted with a possible health issue involving your product, and have had to make real-time decisions about what to do, you know how tough it is. You certainly dont want to under-react if theres real risk your food might be dangerous to people, but you also dont want to over-react if your food really isnt a danger.
And the question is, what happens if FDA does that, but it turns out later to have been wrong?
Build Your Case On Time
When suing the government, you need to file a notice of claim before filing a lawsuit in court.
The notice of claim may vary depending on whether you are suing the federal or state government and may vary from one agency to the next. It is typically one to three pages long.
In the notice of claim, you must state that you have a claim against certain government employees or government, explain the basic facts surrounding your claim and, in some cases, must state the amount of money you are seeking.
The purpose of a notice of claim is to give the government a period of time to investigate your claims. The government may wish to settle your case outside of court. In most cases, however, the government will deny your claim or simply allow the claim to expire by failing to settle within a specified period of time, and you will need to bring a lawsuit after the notice of claim period expires.
There are strict time limitations that apply to claims against government agencies. The time limitations are often significantly shorter than the time limits on filing claims against private individuals or corporations. Failure to abide by these time limits may result in dismissal of your claim against the government entity.
Q What Is A Notice Of Tort Claim
A. A form that you must complete and file if a New Jersey government entity or employee injures you. You generally must file the form with the entity within 90 DAYS from the date of the accident. After that, the two-year deadline to file a lawsuit still applies. If you miss the 90-day deadline, you lose your right to sue the government entity and any responsible employee. Note that you cant file a lawsuit until six months expire after you file your notice of tort claim.
Read Also: Dental Grants For Seniors
The Federal Tort Claims Act
Do you need permission to sue the government? No, but you must comply with the provisions of the Federal Tort Claims Act. In 1946, Congress passed the Federal Tort Claims Act which allows plaintiffs injured by the negligent acts of federal employees to file claims against the United States for damages. Our firm has a national FTCA practice and has represented many clients in cases against the US Government.
Suing the government for personal injury or property damage is not an easy process. Before you can sue the U.S. government for personal injury, you must present an administrative claim within 2 years of the date of negligence to the appropriate federal agency. After the claim is filed, the U.S. government has a minimum of six months to take action on the claim before suit can be filed. During this time, the government usually conducts an investigation on the matter and may or may not offer the plaintiff a settlement.
If, after six months, the government takes no action or if a settlement is not reached, a suit can be filed in federal court. Depending on the circumstances of the case, you may have to comply with additional state laws before you can file your case, depending on the jurisdiction. Talk to your lawyer about what conditions must be satisfied before bringing a lawsuit against the U.S. government. You have a limited amount of time in which to file suit in federal court and if you dont file in a timely manner, you forfeit your right to sue.
Important Information You Need To Know If Youve Been Hurt By The Negligence Of A Federal Entity
If you or a loved one were hurt or died due to the negligence of a federal agency or employee, the Federal Tort Claims Act gives you the right to file a claim for your damages. The FTCA provides certain procedural steps you must follow in order to successfully file an injury claim. Before initiating legal action, you should know what you can sue for and how you must go about it.
Your FTCA claim must be against a federal employee, not an independent contractor, for negligent conduct conducted during the scope of the federal employees employment. Usually, only claims of negligence and not willful misconduct are allowed under the FTCA unless the misconduct was perpetrated by a federal law enforcement official. State laws where the incident took place must also allow claims to be filed for the tortious action perpetrated against you.
Recommended Reading: Rtc Bus Driver Salary Las Vegas
Multistate Lawsuits By Topic
The following chart lists some, but not all, of the multistate lawsuitsA multistate lawsuit is a lawsuit joined by multiple states. For example, in 2018, New York filed a lawsuit in federal court against the repeal of the Open Internet Order. New York was joined by 21 states in the lawsuit. This is a multistate lawsuit. filed against the federal government from 2017-2021. Please contact Ballotpedia at with multistate lawsuits that should be included on this chart.
|Multistate lawsuits against the federal government, 2017-2021|
|Monday, March 13, 2017|
Suing The Local Government: The Section 1983 Lawsuit
Individuals whose constitutional rights are violated by the state government are legally entitled to file a civil action to recover damages. This can be done because of Section 1983, an abridged term for 18 U.S.C. Section 1983, which provides US citizens the right to sue government officials and employees. To establish a claim under Section 1983, it requires two elements:
Therefore, some examples of scenarios where Section 1983 can be a cause of action are:
- A local government official abusing his position or authority
- A county sheriff violating your constitutional rights
- State officials implementing an unconstitutional law
The above scenarios involve suing the local government where one of its personnel committed the violation. However, there is also another way of suing the local government itself its when a policy caused the violation of rights. In this case, policy is defined in legal terms as inclusive of official rules, policy makers decisions, and common practices that are informal policies.
You May Like: What Is Of306
How Do You Sue The Us Government
Generally, a sovereign government cannot be sued unless itallows itself to be sued. In the United States, Congress has passedthe Federal Tort Claims Act allowing the U.S. government tobe sued for the tortious negligence of its employees that causespersonal injury or property damage.
Prior to bringing a lawsuit under the Federal Tort Claims Act,it is required that a written claim be presented to the offendinggovernment agency. After the written claim is presented, six monthsmust pass before a lawsuit may be filed in United States DistrictCourt. If the claim is denied in writing by the agency, theclaimant must file suit within six months of the date ofdenial.
Generally, a written claim must be presented within two years ofreasonable knowledge of the cause and existence of the injury, evenfor minors and incompetents. There are numerous other details andrestrictions under the FTCA and it is advisable to have an attorneyrepresent you in this potentially complicated area of the law.Other laws that allow claims to be made against the United Statesgovernment, but do not allow a lawsuit may also apply such as theMilitary Claims Act and Foreign Claims Act .
Can Us Citizens Sue The Government
Sovereign immunity has carried over to modern times in the form of a general rule that you cannot sue the government unless the government says you can. Fortunately, the Federal Tort Claims Act allows certain kinds of lawsuits against federal employees who are acting within the scope of their employment.
Don’t Miss: Government Jobs In San Antonio
How To Sue The Federal Government
This article was written by Jennifer Mueller, JD. Jennifer Mueller is an in-house legal expert at wikiHow. Jennifer reviews, fact-checks, and evaluates wikiHow’s legal content to ensure thoroughness and accuracy. She received her JD from Indiana University Maurer School of Law in 2006.There are 11 references cited in this article, which can be found at the bottom of the page. This article has been viewed 47,887 times.
Typically, you can’t sue the federal government. However, the Federal Tort Claims Act provides a limited right for private citizens to file a lawsuit in federal court against a federal government agency for negligence or personal injury claims. You may have a lawsuit under the FTCA if, for example, you were hit by a postal service truck while crossing the street, or you slipped and fell in a Social Security office. A lawsuit under the FTCA is more complicated than a basic personal injury lawsuit against another individual or a private business, and you must first exhaust administrative remedies before you have the right to sue the federal government.XResearch source
How To Maximize Your Claim Against The Federal Government
When youre hurt because of an accident that involves a federal agent or employee, there are things that you can do to maximize your claim. Its important to understand that you have a right to bring your claim, but the victim must prove what compensation they deserve. They have a right to full compensation under the law that applies.
An experienced personal injury attorney for federal lawsuit claims can help determine what you stand to receive in compensation and what you can do to assert your rights.
Don’t Miss: State Jobs In Las Vegas
When And How You Can Sue The Government
If you feel that a U.S. government employee or agency violated your rights, you can sue them. To do so, you will file a lawsuit pursuant to the Federal Tort Claims Act. But what is the Federal Tort Claims Act, and how can you use it to help you?
Cases To Which The United States Is A Party
SECTION 2. Clause 1. The Judicial Power shall extend to all Cases, in Law and Equity, arising under this Constitution, the Laws of the United States, and Treaties made, or which shall be made, under their Authority to all Cases affecting Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls to all Cases of admiralty and maritime Jurisdiction to Controversies to which the United States shall be a Party to Controversies between two or more States between a State and Citizens of another State between Citizens of different States,between Citizens of the same State claiming Land under Grants of different States, and between a State, or the Citizens thereof, and foreign States, Citizens or Subjects.
Because suits against the United States can be maintained only by congressional consent, it follows that they can be brought only in the manner prescribed by Congress and subject to the restrictions imposed.1016 As only Congress may waive the immunity of the United States from liability, officers of the United States are powerless either to waive such immunity or to confer jurisdiction on a federal court.1017 Even when authorized, suits may be brought only in designated courts,1018 and this rule applies equally to suits by states against the United States.1019 Congress may also grant or withhold immunity from suit on behalf of government corporations.1020
996 3 J. Story, Commentaries On The Constitution Of The United States 1274 , .
1003 136 U.S. 211 .
1007 295 U.S. 463 .
Recommended Reading: Harford County Careers
Can A Lawyer File A Sf95 Notice Of Claim For Me
Yes. SF95 forms have a field to identify the legal representative filing your claim. Because there are specific procedural steps to be taken, an attorney familiar with the FTCA can help ensure your paperwork is processed correctly. Attorneys can help claimants with aspects such as:
Time deadlines: Notice of Claims often must be filed within two years of the injury . Utilizing the services of an attorney can help ensure your claim is filed in a timely manner to preserve your rights. Once your claim is submitted, the federal government has six months to make a decision on your claim.
Once the government rules on your notice of claims, you have six months to file a lawsuit if you are not awarded the full amount of money you asked for. Consult with a DC personal injury lawyer to determine which deadline applies to your injury case.
Supporting documents: Notice of Claims usually must include supporting documents for their injuries and/or property damage. Attorneys can assist in collecting documentation recording the extent of the injury, hospitalization, treatment, the degree of any disabilities. In wrongful death cases, you may need to include invoices for burial expenses.
Is The Government Responsible For Your Business Losses
The facts of your claim are very important in determining whether the government can be held liable for damage to your business. Generally, the government is not responsible for having a passive role in causing harm to a business. However, when damages are caused by the negligent act of someone working for the government and that act was within the scope of their employment, the government may be liable.
If you were harmed by the negligence of a government employee or if you think you may have a claim against the government, contact our office to discuss your options.
If you have questions, need the advice of a trusted counselor, or simply do not know where to turn, our team is here to help. Contact us today to schedule a free consultation.
Recommended Reading: Congress Mortgage Stimulus Program 2019
How To File A Ftca Claim
Once you have exhausted your administrative remedies meaning, youre not satisfied with the offer you received from the federal agency you can now file a lawsuit against the federal government.
To file an administrative claim, you need to fill out Standard Form 95 or SF 95 for short, which you can from any federal agency website. Instructions on how to fill out SF 95 form and where to send it are provided on the document.
Some of the information you need to provide on the SF 95 form include:
- The name of the appropriate federal agency
- Your name, address, and date of birth
- The date and time of the accident or incident
- The basis of the claim
- Information on the nature and extent of the personal injury, wrongful death, or property damage
- Names and addresses of the witnesses
- The amount of the claim
- Information regarding the insurance coverage of the damaged property or vehicle
Once youve gone through the administrative process, only then can you sue the government in federal court to seek monetary compensation.
It is worth noting that the government pays out millions of dollars every year in Federal Tort Claims Act settlements. Therefore, despite the numerous limitations placed on these claims, it is worth pursuing if you believe you have a valid case.
Are you currently dealing with a legal issue? with a Laws101 attorney right now.
Sovereign Immunity In The United States
|This article needs to be . Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information.|
In United States law, the federal government as well as state and tribal governments generally enjoy sovereign immunity, also known as governmental immunity, from lawsuits. Local governments in most jurisdictions enjoy immunity from some forms of suit, particularly in tort. The Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act provides foreign governments, including state-owned companies, with a related form of immunitystate immunitythat shields them from lawsuits except in relation to certain actions relating to commercial activity in the United States. The principle of sovereign immunity in US law was inherited from the English common law legal maximrex non potest peccare, meaning “the king can do no wrong.” In some situations, sovereign immunity may be waived by law.
Sovereign immunity falls into two categories:
- Absolute immunity: When absolute immunity applies, a government actor may not be sued for the allegedly wrongful act, even if that person acted maliciously or in bad faith and
- Qualified immunity: When qualified immunity applies, the government actor is shielded from liability only if specific conditions are met, as specified in statute or case law.
Read Also: Congress Mortgage Stimulus For Middle Class